This marks the first major decision of general manager Ian Cunningham's tenure. Despite being a top free agent target, the Falcons prioritized retaining Pitts, who led the team with 928 receiving yards and five touchdowns in 2025.
The move surprised many, with reactions ranging from relief to frustration over injuries. Some highlighted the correlation between Pitts' resurgence and quarterback Kirk Cousins, while others lamented the loss of a top free agent option.